Facing issues with an aging toilet might lead you to believe a replacement is imminent. However, opting for a new toilet installation Toronto, though it seems like a straightforward solution for troublesome fixtures, might not always be the most suitable approach for the problem at hand. Acquiring some repair skills can empower you to address minor problems, potentially saving you from the expense and effort of acquiring a new toilet.

It’s crucial to discern when a toilet requires replacement and when a repair might suffice. To assist in making this determination, we’ve compiled an exhaustive guide aimed at providing you with insights on choosing between toilet replacement and repair. Continue reading to gain a deeper understanding!

Indications That It’s Time for a New Toilet

Be mindful of these indicators suggesting it might be time to consider replacing your toilet.

  1. Unexpected Increase in Water Expenses

One of the subtle hints that your toilet is nearing its expiration is an unexpected rise in your water bill. A deteriorating toilet will often consume more water as it struggles to perform its basic functions, leading to an increase in your water expenses. In contrast, installing a modern, efficient toilet can significantly reduce water usage and, consequently, lower your bills due to its improved efficiency in water management.

  1. Frequent Problems: Clogs, Continuous Running, or Overflows 

Persistent issues such as overflows should prompt immediate consultation with a plumbing expert. Water mismanagement can lead to structural harm or encourage mold proliferation, potentially incurring greater expenses than mere toilet maintenance or replacement.

An isolated overflow incident doesn’t always signal the need for a new toilet. However, recurrent overflows, clogging, or a toilet that constantly runs can indicate it’s time for a replacement. Besides being a nuisance, a continuously running toilet suggests internal damage and inefficiency, signaling the end of its useful life. Regular clogs could point towards problematic pipes, but a comprehensive inspection might reveal the necessity for a new toilet to resolve these issues permanently.

  1. Escalating Repair Demands

Frequent malfunctions, such as inadequate flushing, often hint at underlying issues like blocked pipes or obsolete components, signaling that your toilet may require attention. The need for constant repairs or patching up cracks signifies it might be time for an upgrade. Opting for a new toilet could spare you the inconvenience and cost of repeated maintenance.

  1. Visible Cracks or Leaks

Visible damage, like cracks or leaks, especially in older toilets, typically indicates that the toilet’s lifespan is concluding. Such defects not only lead to water wastage but could also cause additional damage to your property. While minor cracks might be manageable with DIY solutions from a hardware store, significant leaks or cracks, particularly at the toilet’s base, necessitate professional intervention. Promptly addressing leaks can prevent further damage, but extensive leaking often means a replacement is the most prudent choice.

Replacing an old, inefficient toilet with a new model can offer numerous benefits, from reducing water bills and minimizing the risk of water damage to improving the overall functionality and appearance of your bathroom.

Indicators Your Toilet Needs Repair

Should your toilet’s issues not align with the previously mentioned scenarios, a replacement might not be necessary. Here’s a detailed look at the telltale signs indicating your toilet requires repairs:

  • Inefficient Flushing

Encountering the need for multiple flushes to clear the bowl points to potential problems like low water levels, blockages in the trap or sewer lines, or a flapper that closes too soon. Such issues not only lead to increased water usage and higher bills but might also escalate into more severe complications. Consulting with a professional plumber is advisable to pinpoint and rectify the specific repair needed.

  • Incomplete Refilling of Tank or Bowl

A common toilet issue is the tank or bowl failing to refill post-flush, often due to issues with the fill valve. Replacing the fill valve is a solution, but ensures compatibility with your toilet model. A professional plumber can assist in accurately addressing this problem.

  • Water Pooling at Toilet Base

Noticing water around your toilet’s base usually signals a leak, likely from a compromised seal. Promptly replacing the seal is crucial to prevent the minor leak from becoming a major, costlier issue.

  • Persistent Running Water

A toilet that runs continuously, even without being flushed, suggests a problem with the flapper valve not sealing properly. While adjusting the flapper might temporarily fix the issue, persistent problems may require the replacement of the valve. Enlisting a plumber’s help can confirm if the flapper valve is at fault.

  • Rust and Corrosion

Discovering rust or corrosion on your toilet’s metal components during cleaning indicates that these parts are deteriorating and need replacement. While not all corrosion signals a complete toilet overhaul, localized rust can be managed by replacing the affected parts.

  • Delayed Tank Refill

A tank that refills sluggishly could point to a malfunctioning shut-off valve. Inspecting and possibly replacing the shut-off valve can remedy this issue. Additionally, low water levels in the bowl might hint at a partial clog or, in conjunction with water around the base, a leak.

  • Malfunctioning Toilet Handle

Frequent use can lead to a loose or stuck toilet handle, impacting flushing efficiency. A plumber can easily adjust or replace the handle to restore proper function.

Addressing these repair signs promptly can save you from unnecessary replacements, ensuring your toilet’s longevity and optimal performance.

Maintaining Your Toilet for Optimal Using

Following the repair or replacement of your toilets, proper maintenance is key to ensuring its continued optimal functionality. Here are essential tips for caring for your toilets:

Routine Cleaning

Regular cleaning not only maintains the aesthetic appeal of your toilets but also prevents damage from improper cleaning agents. Avoid using in-tank cleaners as they can degrade the rubber components and other materials inside the tank.

For bowl cleaning, choose solutions that are safe for porcelain to avoid any risk of staining. This ensures your toilets remains clean without compromising the integrity of its surfaces.

Mindful Flushing Practices

Toilets are primarily designed to handle human waste and toilet paper. It’s crucial to adhere to this guideline strictly. Flushing anything beyond these can not only harm your toilet but also affect the plumbing system adversely.

Being mindful of what gets flushed will significantly reduce the risk of clogs and potential damage to your toilet’s plumbing, ensuring long-term reliability and efficiency.


Operating toilets is straightforward, yet when issues arise, identifying the root cause often requires expertise. Fortunately, most toilet components can be fixed or substituted by engaging a skilled plumber. If you’re uncertain about replacing your old toilets, seeking advice from a plumber can assist in preventing your toilet from leading to costly or significant damage.